Free tool
🇦🇺🇺🇸 Australia & USCan I actually get a refund?
A shop refusing a refund isn’t the end of the conversation — but what you can demand next depends heavily on which country you bought in, and the two are genuinely different, not just differently worded.
In the United States, goods sold by a merchant carry an implied warranty of merchantability: a promise, automatic and unwritten, that they are fit for the ordinary purpose goods of that kind are used for. A salesperson’s specific factual claim, or a description or demo model, creates an express warranty on top of that. Where there is a written warranty, the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act stops the implied warranties being disclaimed and lets a consumer who wins recover attorney fees. What US law does not give you is the right to simply choose a refund: repair is usually the first remedy, and a refund becomes realistic once repair attempts have failed.
In Australia the mechanic is different. The Australian Consumer Law sorts failures into major and minor, and for a major failure the choice of remedy is yours — refund or replacement, not whatever the seller prefers.
Neither country gives you a right to return something because you changed your mind. In the US that is worth one extra check: several states require a retailer to conspicuously post its refund policy and give you a right to return if it did not.
Pick your country below and the tool will apply the right rulebook, including the exact line to use against a deflection like a credit-only offer, a "no refunds" sign, or a manufacturer redirect.
Frequently asked questions
US: what is the implied warranty of merchantability?
An automatic, unwritten promise that comes with almost anything you buy from a merchant: that the goods are fit for the ordinary purpose goods of that kind are used for. Nobody has to say it or write it — it attaches by law under your state’s version of the Uniform Commercial Code. It is the closest thing the US has to a general consumer guarantee, and it is the claim most people never know they have.
US: can a store cut off my warranty by selling something "as is"?
Sometimes, but not as easily as sellers imply. An "as is" disclaimer generally has to be conspicuous and made at the time of sale, not produced afterwards. It cannot be used at all where a written warranty was given, because the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act forbids disclaiming implied warranties in that situation. And a minority of states — Massachusetts, Connecticut, Kansas, Maine, Maryland, Mississippi, Vermont, West Virginia and DC among them — restrict or prohibit disclaiming implied warranties in consumer sales outright.
US: can I insist on a refund instead of a repair?
Usually not straight away, and this is where US and Australian law genuinely diverge. A seller or warrantor is generally entitled to try to repair first. What they are not entitled to is unlimited attempts: once a reasonable number have failed and the fault persists, the remedy has failed its essential purpose, and a refund or replacement comes into play. Keep a dated log of every attempt — the count is the whole argument.
US: the store sent me to the manufacturer. Do I have to go?
It is often worth doing, because the manufacturer’s written warranty may be the fastest route to a repair and Magnuson-Moss governs how they handle it. But it does not let the retailer off. They sold you goods that had to be merchantable, and that obligation is theirs regardless of what the warranty card says. Pursue both at once rather than treating the hand-off as the end of the road.
US: does paying by credit card help?
Considerably. You can dispute the charge with your issuer under the Fair Credit Billing Act, which runs on its own timetable and does not need the seller to cooperate. The Act also lets you assert against the issuer the same claims and defences you have against the seller for larger purchases, subject to conditions. Always open the card dispute in parallel rather than waiting for the seller to say no.
Are "no refunds" signs even legal?
The sign itself isn’t illegal, but relying on it to refuse a genuine consumer guarantee claim can be. The ACCC treats a blanket "no refunds" sign used against a faulty-goods claim as potentially misleading conduct — it can only ever govern change-of-mind returns, which were never a legal right in the first place.
Refund or repair — who actually chooses?
It depends on whether the failure is major or minor. For a major failure, you choose between a refund and a replacement. For a minor failure, the seller gets to choose the remedy — usually a repair — but they still have to provide it, and within a reasonable time.
How long do my refund rights last?
There’s no fixed cutoff. The ACL guarantees last for a "reasonable time," which depends on what you paid and what kind of product it is — a cheap accessory and an expensive appliance aren’t held to the same durability expectation.
Does "change of mind" give me any rights?
No. Change-of-mind returns are entirely a matter of store policy, not law. If the store offers one, that’s a courtesy, not an obligation — check their current published policy before assuming it applies.
Can the store send me to the manufacturer instead?
No. The retailer who sold you the product is the one who owes you the consumer guarantee remedy. A manufacturer’s warranty is a separate, additional thing — it doesn’t replace or redirect your claim against the seller.
Do I need the original receipt?
You need proof of purchase, which is broader than the paper receipt — a bank statement, order confirmation email, or store account record can all work.
Related dispute guides
Other free tools
screwtheman.com is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. This tool gives general information on consumer rights and dispute pathways based on public guidance. For complex legal matters, consult a qualified lawyer or the relevant regulator.