How do I make a debt collector prove I owe the debt?
How to demand written validation of a debt from a US collector, the limits on how and when they may contact you, and how to escalate to the CFPB or your state attorney general.
Regulator
CFPB
Key legislation
Fair Debt Collection Practices Act
Dispute path
Letter first, deadline tracked. If they go quiet, escalation to CFPB is prepped and ready.
A third-party collector contacting you about a debt must send a written validation notice setting out the amount, the creditor, and your right to dispute it. If you dispute the debt in writing, the collector must stop collection activity until it sends you verification. That pause is not a courtesy — it is the mechanism, and it is why the written dispute matters far more than any phone conversation.
The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act and Regulation F also restrict how they may pursue you. They may not contact you before 8am or after 9pm in your local time, may not contact you at work once you have told them not to, and are limited in how often they may call about a particular debt. They may not threaten action they cannot lawfully take, and they may not discuss the debt with anyone other than you or your spouse or attorney.
Two things are worth knowing before you engage. Never acknowledge that a debt is yours until it has been validated — with an old debt, an acknowledgement or a small payment can restart the statute of limitations and revive something that was no longer enforceable. And if the debt is not yours at all, say precisely that in writing, because identity theft and misapplied accounts are common and are handled differently from a dispute about the amount.
Frequently asked questions
What exactly should I ask for?
Written verification of the debt: the original creditor, the amount, an accounting of how it was calculated, and evidence that the collector has the right to collect it. Send it in writing and keep proof of delivery.
Can I make them stop contacting me?
Yes. A written request that they cease contact generally requires them to stop, apart from telling you what happens next. Be aware that stopping contact does not make the debt go away, and can push them toward a lawsuit instead — so use it deliberately rather than as a first move.
What if the debt is very old?
Every state has a statute of limitations on suing over a debt, after which it cannot be enforced in court. Making a payment or admitting the debt in writing can restart that clock in many states. Check your state before you say or pay anything.
They keep calling my workplace. Is that allowed?
Not once you have told them not to. Tell them in writing that you may not receive calls at work, keep a copy, and log every call afterwards with the date and time — that log is what a complaint is built on.
Where do I complain?
The CFPB takes debt collection complaints and forwards them to the collector, and your state attorney general enforces state collection rules that are often stricter than the federal ones. Filing with both is normal.
What if debt collector just ignores my letter?
Silence is not a dead end, it is a deadline breach. debt collector is expected to respond to a formal complaint within 30 days. Build your letter with us and we track that deadline for you: a countdown check-in two weeks in, and if they miss the deadline, your escalation to the CFPB (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau) arrives pre-filled and ready to lodge. Escalating is free.
Related fights
screwtheman.com is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. The content on this page is for general information on consumer rights, legislation, and dispute pathways. For complex legal matters, consult a qualified lawyer or the relevant regulator.